Google+ or Facebook: Which is Better for Social Media Marketing?

Alan Robezzoli • September 12, 2012

Note: The post below was created in 2012.  As of April 2, 2019, Google shut down the consumer (personal) version of Google+, so please interpret the article below from a historical perspective.
Overview:
While Facebook is king, Google Plus is a worthwhile and powerful marketing tool that you can’t really afford to ignore. Here's why ...

Red boxing gloves labeled Google+ and Facebook facing off, comparing the two networks for social media marketing

Apples and Oranges?

When it comes to marketing, it’s been said that comparing Google Plus to Facebook is like comparing apples to oranges. Both are powerful tools, and both can be used in very different ways – so if you want to promote your business online and are already fluid in social networks like Facebook, but aren’t yet active on Google Plus, then maybe it’s time to take a closer look at Google Plus.

Why? Because Google Plus is a worthwhile and powerful marketing tool that you can’t really afford to ignore. I have many colleagues and clients who aren’t yet convinced (as of 2012), and stick with what they know (Facebook). However, there are many advantages to using both Facebook and Google Plus.

Introducing Google Plus

When Google Plus first came onto the scene, the Google Plus One button was initially compared to the Facebook ‘like’ button, which gave the impression that Google Plus was just like another version of Facebook. And not only that, but Facebook Fan Pages have also been compared to Google Plus Business Pages.

Currently, many businesses spend up to thousands of dollars on Facebook promotion and advertising, and many of the companies which provide Facebook marketing and social media marketing do not offer the same services when it comes to Google Plus.

This has put Google Plus in the dark for many business owners who have been led to believe that Google Plus is not a worthwhile marketing or commercial platform.

The great advantage of Google Plus is that it’s so much more than just a social platform – it’s a part of Google, and can impact your search results on Google.com. If you think of Facebook as straightforward, black and white, then Google Plus will introduce an entire rainbow of colourful tools to your marketing strategies. Here’s why:

Integrated Across Google Products

Google Plus is heavily integrated with a range of products, such as Google Search, Google Reader, Google Docs, YouTube, Picassa and much more. It also has direct integration with Google Chat and Google Voice. The net effect is the ability to leverage your efforts across more channels.

Google Plus and YouTube are also in the process of integrating, with Google Plus comments for YouTube videos – great if like me, you’re currently marketing with video, as Google Plus provides another platform to get more views and traffic to your website.

Google Plus Hangouts

What are Hangouts, you ask? Google Plus hangouts can be a powerful tool for meeting new people, joining discussions, or participate in live social interactions. Think of a hangout as similar to going to a dinner party – you can make personal connections and new contacts from the comfort of your own computer, and you can use hangouts in a variety of interactive ways.

Google Plus Circles

Unlike Facebook, Google Plus utilizes a one-sided action where you can add people to your circles. In turn, they can add you to theirs. In a case of internet imitating life, you can create your own circles according to friends, family, business, or interests. You can then easily share information with one circle without the other one knowing.

Extra Visibility in Google Social Search

The more you use Google Plus, the more potential impact, reach, and visibility you’ll have your Google Plus posts on Google Search Your World – or GSYW (Google Personal Social Search).

Contact PMI for Help With Your Internet Marketing Strategy

In terms of business, Google Plus can provide you with additional reach, visibility and potential contacts. Facebook is optimized for friends. Google Plus offers many advantages for business. To learn more about how you can execute a winning social media strategy, contact us today.

Woman on a Reading PA sidewalk checking a fast contractor site on her phone, core web vitals
By Alan Robezzoli • November 2, 2026
Core Web Vitals for small business: what LCP, INP and CLS measure, how much they affect rankings and revenue, and the mobile-first fixes that speed up a site.
Hand clicking a tally counter at a Reading PA shop door, a metaphor for GA4 conversion tracking
By Alan Robezzoli • October 29, 2026
GA4 conversion tracking for small businesses: plan key events, set up Google Tag Manager, test in DebugView and choose the right GA4 attribution settings.
Open wooden card catalog drawer with navy and saffron index tabs, symbolizing on-page SEO structure
By Alan Robezzoli • October 15, 2026
On-page SEO guide for small businesses: map keywords to pages, write title tags and meta descriptions, structure headings, and build internal links that rank.
Business owner at an Allentown office monitor reviewing a Google Ads campaign structure by ad group
By Alan Robezzoli • October 14, 2026
Google Ads campaign structure explained: when to split campaigns, how tight ad groups should be, which match types to use, and how audience targeting works.
Paper phone wireframes pinned in sequence on a cork board, planning a conversion-focused web page
By Alan Robezzoli • October 8, 2026
Conversion-focused web design explained: page order, messaging, phone-first layout, CTA design, short forms and landing pages that turn visits into leads.
Printed marketing analytics reports and a laptop dashboard on a table for a small business review
By Alan Robezzoli • September 28, 2026
Marketing analytics for small business, explained: GA4 tracking, funnel KPIs, attribution, cost per lead, ROI and reports that turn data into decisions.