5 Outdated SEO Tactics That Could Harm Your Rankings

Alan Robezzoli • November 27, 2018

If you’ve been working on search engine optimization (SEO) for any length of time, it may be difficult to let go of certain SEO tactics. You may think, “This tactic has worked in the past so why change it now?” We’ll tell you why: because Google is constantly getting more sophisticated and smarter in how they rank websites, so what worked yesterday, won’t necessarily work as well (or maybe at all) today, and in some cases the old tactics may even hurt your ranking. If you insist on hanging on to those outdated tactics, you may find yourself spinning your wheels without gaining the desired results.

Here are five outdated tactics and new strategies to replace them:

1 - Focusing Exclusively on Obtaining a High Search Ranking

Ranking number one on Google’s SERP has long been the brass ring for many marketers. Being number one isn’t worth as much as it once was. You will also get real value from other traffic-driving SEO techniques. Instead of rankings alone, also focus on SERP factors like the “featured snippet”, which is used in voice search and doesn’t need to come from a number one ranking result. Other features to focus on include image SEO, local SEO, and news SEO . Long tail targeting (targeting longer search phrases) which targets less competitive keywords, is another way to go.

2 - AdWords/Keyword Planner-Based Keyword Research

Many people tend to start their keyword research with Google’s AdWords/Keyword Planner-based tools and only then start using more sophisticated tools. The problem with this tactic is that AdWords hides a lot of keywords their algorithms don’t “think” are commercially relevant, thereby making your results inaccurate and too imprecise. In addition, this approach lacks several critical metrics such as click-through rate percentage and ranking difficulty, which you need to consider when prioritizing keywords. It’s better to start with a broader, more informed strategy. Try using paid tools like SEMrush or Keyword Explorer. It will cost you more upfront, but you’ll end up with more effective keywords.

3 - Subdomains and Separate Domains

Sometimes companies decide they want to dominate the first page of the SERP. To achieve this, they may decide to register separate domains or add a bunch of subdomains to their website. This tactic hasn’t worked since Google began giving priority to multiple subpages in a single SERP from one domain. I.e,, use sub-pages instead of subdomains.

4 – Relying on Link Building Alone to Improve Rankings

Often marketers will find themselves ranking maybe fifth or tenth, and they use link building to push their way to the top. This tactic worked well a few years ago, but this alone is no longer enough. Link building is still a powerful tool, but there are other options needed to round out an effective strategy. Instead, focus on searcher task accomplishment, user experience (UX) optimization, improving the quality and depth of content on your page, and brand growth (associating your brand with the topic or keyword).

5 - Obsessing Over Keyword Placement

Yes, keyword placement is still crucial, but you don’t have to spend hours and hours making sure that all the keywords are perfectly placed on your web pages in your “title tags”, headline tags, and the URL, and then repeating those keywords a certain number of times within the page text. Given Google’s improved algorithms, a better tactic is to focus more on creating great content that includes related keywords and related topics in the body of the text, and deep content that thoroughly explains the topics, keywords, phrases, and subjects that Google knows users associate with those particular topics. Google is getting more and more focused on providing content that solves the users’ queries, and they’re getting savvier by the day about how to make that happen, which is why using related keywords is more relevant than ever.
BOTTOM LINE:
Try replacing these outdated SEO tactics with the above strategies - you will likely be pleasantly surprised by the results!

Want to Achieve Better SEO the Easy Way?

How well are your current SEO tactics working? Use our FREE SEO Checkup . Then, call the experts at ( 484) 297-6395 or contact us online to learn how we can improve your website’s ranking the fast and easy way.

Three figures on rising blue columns with a red winner on top, showing how modern SEO beats outdated tactics
Brown Contact Us button inviting readers to ask PMI whether outdated SEO tactics are harming their rankings






This blog is adapted from “ SEO ‘Dinosaur’ Tactics That You Should Retire.”

Owner reviewing a plumbing landing page on a laptop in a Reading PA office for Google Ads
By Alan Robezzoli • November 9, 2026
Google Ads landing pages that convert: match the ad's promise, improve landing page experience and Quality Score, design for phones, and cut form friction.
Business owners talking at an Allentown PA chamber mixer, the relationships behind off-page SEO
By Alan Robezzoli • November 5, 2026
Off-page SEO explained for small businesses: how to earn backlinks properly, what Google calls link spam, and how citations, reviews and PR build authority.
Woman on a Reading PA sidewalk checking a fast contractor site on her phone, core web vitals
By Alan Robezzoli • November 2, 2026
Core Web Vitals for small business: what LCP, INP and CLS measure, how much they affect rankings and revenue, and the mobile-first fixes that speed up a site.
Hand clicking a tally counter at a Reading PA shop door, a metaphor for GA4 conversion tracking
By Alan Robezzoli • October 29, 2026
GA4 conversion tracking for small businesses: plan key events, set up Google Tag Manager, test in DebugView and choose the right GA4 attribution settings.
Open wooden card catalog drawer with navy and saffron index tabs, symbolizing on-page SEO structure
By Alan Robezzoli • October 15, 2026
On-page SEO guide for small businesses: map keywords to pages, write title tags and meta descriptions, structure headings, and build internal links that rank.
Business owner at an Allentown office monitor reviewing a Google Ads campaign structure by ad group
By Alan Robezzoli • October 14, 2026
Google Ads campaign structure explained: when to split campaigns, how tight ad groups should be, which match types to use, and how audience targeting works.